Sunday, September 12, 2010

Reading Research Reflection

Name Stephanie Meyers


Reading Research Notebook

Marzano Chapter 2

Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences



Part 1: Summary

Chapter 2 of the text “Classroom Instruction That Works” focuses on being able to identify similarities and differences. According to the text, “Researchers have found these mental operations to be basic to human thought” (p.14). Studies have found that identifying similarities and differences has led to thirty to forty percent gains in student achievement. Presenting guidance to identify similarities and differences, asking students to independently identify similarities and differences, developing a graphic representation of similarities and differences, and identifying similarities and differences in varied ways help students enhance their understanding. Classroom practice is the best way to perform this strategy. One way to do so is by comparing. Characteristics are established by the teacher and the students then determine the similarities and differences. Venn diagrams and comparison matrices are good examples of graphic organizers that can be used to perform this task. Another way to perform the task is by classifying. To classify, ideas are put into groups based on their similarities; categories are developed. Developing metaphors and analogies are the final two ways the chapter discusses. Both of these tasks involve creating a relationship between two objects. The strategy of identifying similarities and differences allows students to apply knowledge they have developed.

Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class

Chapter 3 in “The Art and Science of Teaching”, also by Marzano, addresses the strategy of identifying similarities and differences just as Chapter 2. Examining similarities and differences is listed as action step to help students practice and deepen their understanding of new knowledge. The four tasks listed in Chapter 2 are also discussed in Chapter 3 of the other text. For the task of comparing, a Venn diagram is recommended, but the author also suggested the idea of a sentence stem. A classification chart was used for the task of classifying. I thought the chapter in “The Art and Science of Teaching” did a good job describing how to perform the tasks of developing metaphors and developing analogies. The text used an example involving Frederick Douglas and Helen Keller. Using the facts about both of them, common characteristics were developed that allowed the learner to understand that opposite things can be similar. Chapter 3 showed provided more ideas for graphic representations.

Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests

After reading the chapter from “Classroom Instruction That Works”, I have realized that the strategy of identifying similarities and differences is important to use in the science classroom. There are many ideas in this content field that are compared. For example, heliocentric versus geocentric models are studied. Another idea that is studied is vertebrates and invertebrates. A Venn diagram is a tool that I can use, to give my students a visual aid, to help them better understand the similarities and differences between two concepts. Metaphors and analogies can also be used for audio learners. For example, when studying resources, the following analogy from the text can be used: “Oxygen is to humans as carbon dioxide is to plants” (p.27). This analogy can be repeated by the students so that the concept is learned; humans depend on oxygen while plants depend on carbon dioxide. The strategy of identifying similarities and differences will be used frequently in my science classroom.

3 comments:

  1. I really liked your specific examples in the science class room. It can be very useful to use venn diagrams for heliocentric versus geocentric. I honestly did not think about those topics until I read your blog. This would give the students a great deal of information and understanding on the topics but not take a great deal of time in the class room (like 2 weeks which you know what I mean). Great job Stephanie.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like how you mentioned the idea of using metaphors and analogies for students who are audio learners. I think it is great how you are looking out for all the different learners in the classroom. I agree that science is a huge subject to tackle. Students need a way to group things and I think you have some great ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ashley and Summer,
    I appreciate how each of you have related with this blog. Pointing out the use of venn diagrams and the importance of addressing multiple types of learners are both important points. Thanks!

    Dr. C.

    ReplyDelete